Welcome to Oaksterdam News Network
Home arrow Volume One arrow V1 Issue 1 arrow US Supreme Court hears medical marijuana case
Adjust Text -
US Supreme Court hears medical marijuana case PDF Print E-mail
Written by Chris Conrad   
With Chief Justice Rehnquist unable to attend due to cancer, eight US Supreme Court Justices heard oral arguments Nov. 29 in Ashcroft v. Raich. The ruling will affect thousands of patients but it will not change state laws protecting medical marijuana. It will give the current Court’s thinking as to whether the Constitution enables the DEA to use federal authority over interstate commerce to arrest and prosecute sick and dying patients who use cannabis in states where medical use is legal.

    Because federal law is a separate jurisdiction, a state medical defense has not been allowed in federal court, but that is being challenged.

David Michael, Diane Monson, Randy Barnett, Angel Raich and Rob Raich
David Michael, Diane Monson, Randy Barnett, Angel Raich and Rob Raich
    If prosecutors win, that disconnect between the laws will stand and may get worse. If patients Angel Raich and Diane Monson win, the federal government will have to make a medical marijuana exception for some cases. Since the court has recently ruled that the feds overstepped their authority by banning child pornography and automatic weapons within state borders, it should be an easy win for medical marijuana.

    However, attendees at the Court hearing were discouraged by the easy questions tossed to prosecutors and the general lack of compassion the tribunal showed toward patients.

    {quotes right}Several judges gave the distinct impression that their vested interest in maintaining the Drug War trumps Constitutional protections of personal liberty,{/quotes} much as the 1857 Dred Scot decision once held that maintaining slavery trumped the civil rights of African Americans. The judges already made their decision in Raich at a conference held shortly after the hearing, but the final ruling has not been announced as of press time.

    Americans for Safe Access is asking supporters of medical rights to organize or attend a protest outside of your US representative's local district office precisely two days after the decision is announced, to show support for safe access.  



 
< Prev   Next >
V3 Issue 2
Best viewed with:
Get Firefox!